By Louise Dennison O’Shaughnessy, Director of Mental Health & Wellness, EHS International

Most managers want to do the right thing when someone on their team is struggling.

The difficulty is knowing what the right thing actually is.

You notice someone has become quieter. Their work is slipping. They are arriving late when they never did before. Perhaps they seem unusually irritable, overwhelmed or distracted.

You know something has changed.

But then the questions start.

Do I ask them about it? What if I embarrass them? What if it is something personal? What if they tell me something I don’t know how to deal with?

So sometimes, despite the best intentions, nothing is said.

You Don’t Need to Diagnose Someone

One of the biggest misconceptions about supporting mental health at work is that managers need to know exactly what is wrong.

They don’t.

A manager’s role is not to diagnose depression, anxiety, burnout or any other mental health condition. Nor should a manager become someone’s counsellor.

Their role is simpler, but still incredibly important.

Notice.

Ask.

Listen.

Support.

And know when to bring in additional help.

A conversation can begin with something as straightforward as:

“I’ve noticed you don’t seem quite yourself recently. How are things?”

You don’t need the perfect words.

What matters more is creating enough space for the person to answer honestly.

Listen Before You Try to Fix It

Managers are often problem-solvers. Someone brings us an issue and our instinct is to find the solution.

Mental health conversations don’t always work that way.

Sometimes the most useful thing you can do initially is listen.

Don’t immediately tell someone what they should do. Don’t compare their situation with something you experienced. Don’t minimise it by saying, “Everyone is under pressure at the moment.”

Instead, ask what would help.

There is a significant difference between saying:

“Here’s what I think you need to do.”

and:

“What would make things more manageable for you right now?”

That question can open a very different conversation.

Look at the Work Too

This is particularly important.

When an employee is struggling, organisations can sometimes focus entirely on the individual.

Are they resilient enough?

Do they need counselling?

Should they contact the EAP?

Would some time off help?

Those supports may absolutely have a place.

But managers should also ask another question:

Is something happening at work that is contributing to this?

Workload. Long hours. Lack of clarity. Conflict. Organisational change. Poor communication. Lack of control. Insufficient staffing. Bullying or inappropriate behaviour.

These are not simply “wellbeing issues”. They can be psychosocial hazards within the workplace.

If somebody is overwhelmed because their workload has been unrealistic for six months, encouraging them to practise better self-care doesn’t address the source of the problem.

Sometimes supporting someone’s mental health means changing something about the work.

Don’t Wait for a Crisis

We are often much better at responding to a visible crisis than noticing what happens before it.

Mental health difficulties don’t always announce themselves dramatically.

Sometimes they look like someone becoming quieter in meetings.

Sometimes it’s a normally organised employee starting to miss deadlines.

Sometimes it’s increased conflict.

Sometimes it’s someone working longer and longer hours.

And sometimes there is no obvious sign at all.

That is why regular, genuine conversations matter.

A manager who knows their team and routinely asks how people are managing creates opportunities for concerns to emerge before they become crises.

Managers Need Support Too

There is another side to this conversation.

We ask managers to notice when employees are struggling, have sensitive conversations, manage workloads, deal with conflict, understand policies and know when situations need to be escalated.

Yet many managers have never been trained to have these conversations.

That isn’t fair on the manager or the employee.

Mental health awareness and appropriate manager training should form part of how organisations prepare people for leadership.

A manager doesn’t need to have all the answers.

They should, however, know how to start the conversation, where the boundaries of their role lie, what internal and external supports are available, and what to do when they are genuinely concerned about someone’s wellbeing.

The Conversation Matters

There will rarely be a perfect moment to ask someone if they are OK.

There probably won’t be a perfect sentence either.

But saying something with genuine care is often better than noticing that someone is struggling and saying nothing because we’re afraid of getting it wrong.

The responsibility of a good manager isn’t to solve another person’s mental health.

It’s to make sure they don’t have to struggle invisibly.

And sometimes that starts with one very simple question:

“How are you really doing?”

If You’re a Manager and You’re Concerned About Someone

You don’t need to have all the answers. A few simple steps can help you start the conversation appropriately.

1. Choose the right moment
Find a private, calm setting where you can speak without interruptions or making the person feel exposed.

2. Say what you’ve noticed
Keep it simple and avoid making assumptions. For example: “I’ve noticed you haven’t seemed quite yourself recently. How are things?”

3. Listen before offering solutions
Give them space to talk. You don’t need to diagnose the problem or immediately know how to fix it.

4. Ask what would help
Consider whether something at work could be contributing to the situation and whether any reasonable changes or additional support could make things more manageable.

5. Know when to seek additional support
Be clear about the boundaries of your role. Know your organisation’s policies, available supports and appropriate escalation routes, particularly if you have concerns about someone’s immediate safety or wellbeing.

Most importantly, don’t let fear of saying the wrong thing stop you from saying anything at all.


louise-website-resdy-300x294 When Someone Is Struggling at Work: What Should a Manager Actually Do?About the Author 

Louise Dennison O’Shaughnessy is Director of Mental Health & Wellness at EHS International. 

Louise works with organisations to take a practical, preventative approach to mental health and psychological safety at work. 

Her work looks beyond how organisations support employees when difficulties arise and considers the workplace factors that may be contributing to those difficulties in the first place. 

Through training, consultancy and organisational support, Louise works with employers and leadership teams to build greater understanding of mental health at work, identify areas of concern and put meaningful supports and preventative measures in place. 


How EHS International Can Help

Managers are often one of the first people to notice when something has changed.

But recognising that someone may be struggling and knowing how to respond are two very different things.

At EHS International, we help organisations give managers and employees the knowledge, confidence and practical tools to respond appropriately to mental health concerns at work, while also looking at the workplace factors that may be contributing to those concerns.

The aim isn’t to turn managers into counsellors or mental health professionals.

It’s to help them understand what their role is, where its boundaries lie and what good support can look like.

Manager Training and Support

Practical training to help managers recognise when someone may be struggling, approach sensitive conversations appropriately, listen without immediately trying to solve the problem and understand when additional support or escalation may be needed.

Training can also help managers understand the boundaries of their role and the internal and external supports available to them and their teams.

Mental Health First Aid and Workplace Mental Health Training

Training designed to strengthen mental health awareness and confidence across the organisation.

This can help employees and managers better understand mental health, recognise potential signs that someone may need support and feel more confident responding appropriately when concerns arise.

Psychosocial Risk Assessments

Supporting an individual is important, but organisations should also consider whether something about the work itself may be contributing to the problem.

Workload, long hours, lack of role clarity, organisational change, conflict, lack of control, insufficient resources and inappropriate behaviour can all contribute to psychosocial risk.

Our psychosocial risk assessments provide a structured approach to identifying workplace factors that have the potential to cause psychological harm, understanding who may be exposed and determining what controls or further action may be required.

Work Positive CI

We can support organisations using Work Positive CI, the State and stakeholder-supported psychosocial risk management process promoted by the Health and Safety Authority.

This provides a structured way to assess workplace stressors, identify areas of concern and inform appropriate organisational action.

ISO 45001 and ISO 45003 Support

For organisations operating an occupational health and safety management system, we can review how psychosocial hazards are currently being identified, assessed and managed.

This can help identify gaps, strengthen existing processes and support alignment with ISO 45003 guidance on psychological health and safety at work.

Not Sure What Your Organisation Needs?

You don’t need to know which service you need before speaking to us.

Perhaps your managers need greater confidence having difficult conversations.

Maybe you’re reviewing your organisation’s overall approach to mental health and wellbeing.

You may have noticed increasing pressure, absence, conflict or workload concerns within a particular team.

Or you may simply want to understand whether what you already have in place is enough.

Start with where your organisation is today.

Tell us what you currently have in place, what you’re seeing and what you’re concerned about, and we’ll help you work out what comes next.

Contact EHS International at [email protected] to start the conversation.